March 20, 2006
Who
Let the Docs Out?
By Laura Gater
For The Record
Vol. 18 No. 6 P. 25
iPods aren’t
just for grooving to tunes. In fact, even the healthcare industry
is gettin’ jiggy with it.
Apple’s iPods—portable
MP3 players with hard disk storage—are popular among people
of all ages who enjoy listening to music at their convenience. The
most powerful devices feature 60 gigabytes (GB) of storage, which
enable consumers to download and store thousands of songs. Not only
does this storage capability equally excite fans of both Bloc Party
and Josh Groban, it also has the medical community sitting up and
taking notice. Apparently, iPods are no longer just for listening
to music.
Medical students are
using iPods to store lectures so they can listen to them later.
Physicians are using them to display and manipulate images, and
the iChat capability can be used to instantly communicate with colleagues.
“Up to a few years
ago, storage was very expensive for mobile devices,” says
Gregory Quinn, PhD, leader of the Mobile Data Visualization group,
San Diego Supercomputer Center, University of California San Diego
(UCSD), who, along with C. Michael Wright, MD, FACC, LifeScore Clinic,
La Jolla, Calif., is researching the potential of mobile device
visualization. “The hardware coming down the pipeline, which
contains graphics accelerators, is very impressive. Mobile devices
are coming to market with micro-drives, primarily intended for MP3
storage, but potentially providing a repository for storing large
amounts of data.”
Image
Storage and Viewing
Two radiologists have developed OsiriX, free downloadable software,
to store and share medical information on iPods. The more powerful
iPods have more storage capability than some laptop computers, making
them ideal for storing and transporting digital imaging and communications
in medicine (DICOM) images. The addition of the iPod to medical
applications has enabled physicians to enhance the picture archiving
and communication system (PACS) with these new features.
Weighing only 5.5 ounces,
60 GB iPods are portable and easy to use. New models have a 2.5-inch
color display, which is ideal for viewing images. Once the images
are on the iPod, they can be carried to another computer—as
long as it is a Macintosh. OsiriX software automatically recognizes
and searches for any images that physicians have stored on their
iPods. When images are detected, they will appear on a list of available
image data, just as music files are displayed.
“I want to emphasize
that the integration of the iPod is just a small feature of the
OsiriX software that was highly acclaimed by the press, but is certainly
not the main reason why physicians will adopt the program,”
explains Osman Ratib, MD, PhD, professor and chief of nuclear medicine
at the University Hospital of Geneva, one of the developers of OsiriX.
“The iPod integration is a perfect example of how our software
takes advantage of ‘disruptive’ technologies that come
from the consumer market and can greatly benefit the professionals
and the medical community in particular. It is part of other tools
such as iChat, used for remote consultations and conferencing; .Mac,
used for online data storage; and Bonjour, used for peer-to-peer
sharing of images and data.
“We took advantage
of all these new technologies that Apple has embedded in their system.
The main revolution that OsiriX brings is the ability to display
and manipulate complex medical images in 3-D, 4-D, and 5-D in a
user-friendly, simple, and accessible way for physicians who are
not necessarily computer experts. These features are only available
so far on high-end, very expensive workstations that were available
to specialists and academic centers. It is like in the video editing
world when tools such as iMovie and iDVD suddenly allowed everybody
to edit and create their own movies in a way that is similar to
the complex video editing of professionals.”
The early PACS workstations
were designed for simple visualization of static images and as a
substitute for light boxes. Today, they have adapted to support
more complex and larger imaging modalities, including 3-D visualization
and reconstructions.
Despite these changes,
PACS technology is limited due to various problems, including a
lack of adequate means of communication and consultation among distant
users; the need to transfer and communicate images constantly from
one location to another, particularly in academic settings; Web-based
PACS systems that are usually slow and have limited image manipulation
capabilities; and emergency medicine that requires fast turnaround
time and 24/7 availability from radiologists.1
Today’s medical
practice relies heavily on images and image data for decision making
and patient management, according to Ratib.
“The tools that
allow physicians to communicate and access the images in a simple
and cost effective way are lagging behind,” he says. “An
increasing number of physicians today need to be able to manipulate
and process complex medical images themselves. Also, there is a
vital need for exchanging and communicating medical images between
physicians and different specialties. This is the problem that OsiriX
is trying to address and provide a solution for.”
According to Ratib,
the OsiriX software was designed to conveniently integrate the iPod
every time it is connected and allows for easy display and manipulation
of the list of images in a similar way to the management of music
files in iTunes, with the advantage of a convenient way to save
and carry data sets when physicians need to transfer patient data
from one location to another.
“It is certainly
faster and more convenient than having to burn the data on a CD
or DVD, or to have to transfer data through complex protected networks,”
Ratib explains. “Furthermore, with the recent generations
of iPod, it is also possible to set OsiriX to store the images in
a format that can also be displayed on the screen of the iPod itself
or on a larger screen or projector that the iPod could be connected
to. This does certainly not have the quality required for diagnostic
purposes, but is convenient for rapid review or presentation of
some key images for discussion of a case or for teaching purposes.”
The iPod has many more
potential uses with the recent adjunction of video streaming and
the ability to download multimedia files and connect to podcasts.
Ratib and his partner, Antoine Rosset, MD, have already demonstrated
the ability to use OsiriX to create podcast movies and add comments
and annotations for teaching and education purposes.
The adoption of OsiriX
has exceeded the doctors’ “wildest expectations.”
In the last two years, they have received several awards, including
the 2005 Apple Design Award for Best Use of Open Source software.
Open Source free software
is emerging as a new strategic solution that can provide tailored
technical solutions for medical users that are being designed and
developed by the users themselves. The great success of OsiriX comes
not only from the large community of users, but also from the fact
that a worldwide community of developers is contributing to the
project and that the source code can be analyzed and edited by anyone
who wants to contribute or modify the program, says Ratib.
Security concerns are
moot. According to Ratib, the software enables physicians to delete
the patient’s personal information from an image file.
Educational
Uses
This year, the Duke University School of Medicine has been making
the audio track for videos available through podcasting for iPods
and other audio devices, according to Pat Thibodeau, MLS, MBA, the
school’s associate dean for library services and archives
who has heard that other medical schools are also doing this. Duke
is also looking into using iPods for audio tutorials, library orientations,
and oral histories of key Duke leaders and figures.
Medical students are
also taking advantage of the iPod’s power by listening to
conference lectures and course review material that is available
for purchase.
“I’ve used
iPods for instructional purposes since last summer with my nursing
informatics students,” explains Linda Goodwin, PhD, RN, BC,
Duke’s director of nursing informatics. “I deployed
them and then had a student do a small pilot study last fall to
test whether students preferred their online lectures via a) streaming
audio [Flash] on the Web, b) podcast, or c) plain old printed slides
with notes. The students mostly seemed to like the Flash versions
better so that they had audio and images at the same time. With
the podcasting, they only heard audio and used printed slides for
note-taking. I have also mailed the iPod to remote guest faculty
who used it to record audio for their lectures and then sent the
iPod back to me so I could compile everything. This wasn’t
always smooth, but it worked fairly well most of the time. I’ve
tried it with audio memos to students, but they seem just as happy
with text versions which are still easier to transmit.”
Goodwin’s class
also used iPods for patient interviews. “We asked 30 individuals
about their personal experiences of patient privacy in the healthcare
system,” she says. “Responses were recorded on the iPod
and downloaded without any identifiers. The recordings were of good
quality. The only problem we encountered was that the interviewer
had to be careful to allow a one- to two-second pause as the recording
began; otherwise, it was cut off. We also had to remind people that
they were not to use names of people or organizations—the
interviewer was instructed to delete any recording that included
anything that could identify a specific person or place. This was
a feasibility analysis and not a formal study so we won’t
use this data, but will be designing future studies that will utilize
this technology to help study issues of patient privacy. The people
interviewed found them unobtrusive and felt comfortable with recorded
data that did not identify who they were.”
NCHICA
Realizes Potential
The North Carolina Healthcare Information and Communications Alliance,
Inc. (NCHICA) is a nonprofit consortium of more than 250 organizations
dedicated to improving healthcare by accelerating the adoption of
IT. Although it hasn’t explored the potential of iPods, NCHICA
realizes the future role of mobile information and storage devices.
“NCHICA wants
to forward adoption of new technologies,” says Martha B. Adams,
MD, MA, associate clinical professor, general internal medicine
and vice chair for clinical affairs-ambulatory at Duke. “The
next educational event by NCHICA regards disease registries. Those,
no doubt, will be enabled with mobile technology, whether laptop
or PDA. I don’t know anyone forward enough for the iPod role
yet, but we’re open to that.”
Adams believes computer
science and multidisciplinary people will help promote the use of
iPods to the next level for medical use. She would like to tout
the winning attributes of iPods and similar mobile devices to those
who are interested in entering the field of medicine so they will
realize the applications of technology not only for education, but
for clinical uses as well.
In addition, Adams is
working on a project with students in the Duke Information Science
and Information Studies program and the medicine house staff to
see whether the iPod will make learning easier. The undertaking
involves building a core curriculum in medicine that can be viewed
online with slides, some of which are interactive.
The
Future
Quinn predicts a convergence among PDAs, iPods, and cell phones
within the next two to three years.
“Physicians will
want to carry one item, and cell phones will have all the capabilities
of the other portable devices. Cell phones will come with a huge
storage capability and powerful graphics, and we will be leveraging
that to end users like physicians and clinicians. Physicians will
be able to do the same things that they have been doing with all
three on their cell phone,” explains Quinn.
Ratib sees the iPod
as advancing rapidly over the coming five years, but still being
an essential tool for physicians.
“In five years,
the iPod will not be the one we know today,” says Ratib. “There
is a light-speed development of portable technologies, and physicians,
being essentially nomads, are very eager to adopt any technology
that will facilitate their work and make the huge amount of information
that they need more accessible to them. I think there will be an
increasing use of this type of technology by medical professionals
where visual communication of images and videos are becoming an
essential part of the information that is needed for patient care
and patient management.”
—
Laura Gater’s medical and business trade articles have been
published in Medical Imaging, 24x7, Podiatry Management, Veterinary
Forum, Corrections Forum, and other national and online publications.
Reference:
1. Proceedings of 19th International Congress of Computer Assisted
Radiology and Surgery, Berlin, Germany
Subscribe to For
the Record Magazine!
|